有在某網站上提問過，但見解上蠻分歧的，

想在這邊跟大家請教。 

請問如果球已經往界外方向去，
假設我方球員試圖將球撥回，
砸到對方球員後出界，
當然球權就回我方。

但有聽過一說，
如果此時對方球員已經跑到界外(線外)
即使砸到對方球員也還是算我方弄出界。
不知是否正確，
謝謝解答~THX

個人認為，雖然對方已跑至界外區，但是他仍然是球隊場上正在比賽的五人之一，球碰觸他他就必須負出責任。以他所站的位置或他起跳的位置來判斷，因此應為我方得界外球。

若因為對手站在界外區，就可以不用對即將出界的界外球負責，那如果該球員雙腳站在界外區，手卻伸進邊線垂直向上的延伸線去碰觸到將會出界的球怎麼辦。這不就是一個bug了嗎？ 

看不懂英文嗎?

"Section II-Ball
a. The ball is out-of-bounds when it touches a player who is out-of-bounds or any other person, the floor, or any object on, above or outside of a boundary or the supports or back of the backboard.
b. Any ball that rebounds or passes directly behind the backboard, in either direction, from any point is considered out-of-bounds.
c. The ball is caused to go out-of-bounds by the last player to touch it before it goes out, provided it is out-of-bounds because of touching something other than a player. If the ball is out-of-bounds because of touching a player who is on or outside a boundary, such player caused it to go out."

http://www.nba.com/analysis/rules_8.html?nav=ArticleList

我比較好奇的是，如果我跳出界外，把球撥回來，然後自己又回到界內拿球，那樣是否違例？

---

網路是屬言論，言論自然是講道理，不講道理乾脆直接去找人輸贏，混網路太可惜了。

個人部落格
http://slightlight.pixnet.net/blog

Slight:

我比較好奇的是，如果我跳出界外，把球撥回來，然後自己又回到界內拿球，那樣是否違例？

如果是救球, 也就是說球已經 lose control, 那是 ok 的, 但是這點其實很多不清楚規則的裁判也會判錯,
如果是球員自己運球過人的時候這樣耍, 則是違例.

24. Player A1 saves a loose ball from going out-of-bounds by batting the ball back onto the playing court. May Player A1 be the first to touch the ball when he returns onto the court?

Yes. The batting of the ball does not constitute player control, therefore Player A1 may be the first to touch the ball.
RULE 10 - SECTION II - b

252. Team A has just lost control of the ball and it is in the air over the boundary line (never having touched out-of-bounds). Player A1 leaps from the playing court, bats the ball back into play and he then lands out-of bounds. What is the ruling?

This is a legal play by Player A1. The ball is not out-of-bounds until it touches someone or something that is out-of-bounds. On this play, Player A1 may also be the first to touch the ball once he touches inbounds with one foot and is not touching out-of-bounds. If Player A1 threw the ball back inbounds, he is not allowed to be the first player to touch the ball.
RULE 8 - SECTION I
RULE 10 - SECTION XIII - g

 

b. A player in control of a dribble who steps on or outside a boundary line, even though not touching the ball while on or outside that boundary line, shall not be allowed to return inbounds and continue his dribble. He may not even be the first player to touch the ball after he has re-established a position inbounds. 

CP003:

Slight:

我比較好奇的是，如果我跳出界外，把球撥回來，然後自己又回到界內拿球，那樣是否違例？

如果是救球, 也就是說球已經 lose control, 那是 ok 的, 但是這點其實很多不清楚規則的裁判也會判錯,
如果是球員自己運球過人的時候這樣耍, 則是違例.

24. Player A1 saves a loose ball from going out-of-bounds by batting the ball back onto the playing court. May Player A1 be the first to touch the ball when he returns onto the court?

Yes. The batting of the ball does not constitute player control, therefore Player A1 may be the first to touch the ball.
RULE 10 - SECTION II - b

252. Team A has just lost control of the ball and it is in the air over the boundary line (never having touched out-of-bounds). Player A1 leaps from the playing court, bats the ball back into play and he then lands out-of bounds. What is the ruling?

This is a legal play by Player A1. The ball is not out-of-bounds until it touches someone or something that is out-of-bounds. On this play, Player A1 may also be the first to touch the ball once he touches inbounds with one foot and is not touching out-of-bounds. If Player A1 threw the ball back inbounds, he is not allowed to be the first player to touch the ball.
RULE 8 - SECTION I
RULE 10 - SECTION XIII - g

 

b. A player in control of a dribble who steps on or outside a boundary line, even though not touching the ball while on or outside that boundary line, shall not be allowed to return inbounds and continue his dribble. He may not even be the first player to touch the ball after he has re-established a position inbounds. 

多謝大師指點，我以前曾在球場上這樣跟人吵起來=3=

---

網路是屬言論，言論自然是講道理，不講道理乾脆直接去找人輸贏，混網路太可惜了。

個人部落格
http://slightlight.pixnet.net/blog